Banjo Brothers Canvas Saddle Bag Review

August 20, 2017

Banjo Brothers Canvas Saddle Bag Review

Looking for a stylish seat bag that can carry everything but a computer for your daily ride? This Banjo Brothers Minnehaha Canvas Bag review may be for you.

Leather and canvas are making their way back into daily cyclist life with Brooks saddles, leather grips, and canvas bags. Canvas bags are what Minnehaha Bags are all about. Minnehaha is run by the same sweet guys at Banjo Brothers, these two guys really understand customer service and deliver a product they believe in. Regardless of the number of clueless emails I've sent to them over the years, they always replied with an upbeat answer and sometimes even photos to explain what I was doing wrong.

One of the best looking (in my opinion) products in the Minnehaha line is the Canvas Saddle Bag, size Medium. The size of the bag is not too daunting when you look at it, there are some saddle bags that really are trunk bags hanging from your saddle. Yet, the size fits everything I could want plus some room for things I didn’t really need.

Minnehaha Canvas Saddle Bag
Size: Medium
Price: $69.99

Details

  • Max. Dimensions: 9″L x 9″H x 11″W – 650 cubic inches / 10L
  • Thick hardwood dowel inside supports heavy loads
  • The main panel of bag is a durable sandwich of 1 1/2 layers of 18oz. canvas, thin padding, and an off-white canvas liner for a brighter interior.
  • Bottom reinforced with a riveted HDPE plate to keep the bag from sagging under load.
  • Exterior lashing points (extra straps not included).
  • Detachable reflective tabs.
  • Interior key/wallet pocket.

Lots of Room in this Seat Bag

Utilizing the capacity of this bag I commuted through February with this bag strapped to the back of my Trek XO cross bike. On a normal day, I had two tubes, two tire levers, a mini pump, multi-tool, spare blinky light, a rain jacket or thick thermal jersey, wallet, keys, phone and a snack. All of this was held inside the bag with room to spare.

Not so Idiot Proof

The saddle that I used to test the bag out with was a WTB Deva, which is considered a racing saddle by many. Yes, they make adapters to clamp on to your rails to make it so you have these rings at the back of your saddle but the thought of clamping anything to my nice titanium saddle rails felt like blasphemy to me. I installed the saddle bag as best as possible and left it that way until I was ready to finish the review. In an email to Mike at Minnehaha, he told me the set up was all wrong. Instead of making one large loop over the seat rails I needed to make two smaller ones.

Banjo Brothers Canvas Saddle Bag Installed Wrong

The leather strap provided wasn’t long enough to achieve the mounting that was recommended so I pulled out a handy toe strap from pedals I no longer use. As you can see below the toe straps are much longer, without the needed holes to clinch down on I was able to also get the bag much tighter to the saddle.

Banjo Brothers Canvas Saddle Bag Installed Properly

When reinstalling the bag correctly I decided to move it to my Salsa Casseroll which will be seeing more commuter mileage through the spring. The new mounting style and ability to really tighten down on the strap made a huge difference on how the bag swung around on the back of the bike. No longer did it rock back and forth or rub as much on the back of my legs.

Overall Conclusion

This bag is stellar. Packing a lunch or my huge DSLR camera is not difficult. The bag is not completely waterproof so keep electronics and valuables in a ziplock bag. I went through a torrential downpour with things at the bottom of my bag surviving but they were damp..Having the weight under you instead of on the front as most people like is better for handling.

The price is right at $69.99 as it carries what I normally put in a pannier which runs about that same price. Order directly from our online store!

This article was originally written by me and published at CommuteByBike.com in 2009. Disclaimer: This bag was provided at no charge for review.



Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Blog

Goodbye Shift Up Podcast, Hello Bike Here Podcast!
Goodbye Shift Up Podcast, Hello Bike Here Podcast!

January 27, 2020

I published the final, "Goodbye" episode on the Shift Up Bike Industry Podcast. It is bittersweet to say goodbye to this project as this was a large fuel to the idea of starting a bike shop!

Continue Reading

Bunch Electric Cargo Bike Overview
Bunch Electric Cargo Bike Overview

January 11, 2020 1 Comment

In this article and video, I'm giving you an overview of the Bunch Family Cargo Bike, specifically their electric trike cargo bike model. Why did I bring this bike into my family bike shop, who is it for, how does it handle and what do I think of the electric assist system?

Continue Reading

Thoughts on Electric and Cargo Bike Pedals
Thoughts on Electric and Cargo Bike Pedals

January 07, 2020 2 Comments

I talk about pedals a lot at the bike shop and while building up a customer's new cargo bike I was reminded about how much a good pedal can change the ride of a bike completely. Here are my musings for pedals on electric and cargo bikes but can probably be applied to any everyday style bike.

Continue Reading

x